• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Corpus Christi Watershed

Pope Saint Paul VI (3 April 1969): “Although the text of the Roman Gradual—at least that which concerns the singing—has not been changed, the Entrance antiphons and Communions antiphons have been revised for Masses without singing.”

  • Donate
  • Our Team
    • Our Editorial Policy
    • Who We Are
    • How To Contact Us
    • Sainte Marie Bulletin Articles
    • Jeff’s Mom Joins Fundraiser
  • Pew Resources
    • Brébeuf Catholic Hymnal
    • Jogues Illuminated Missal
    • Repository • “Spanish Music”
    • KYRIALE • Saint Antoine Daniel
    • Campion Missal, 3rd Edition
  • MUSICAL WEBSITES
    • René Goupil Gregorian Chant
    • Noël Chabanel Psalms
    • Nova Organi Harmonia (2,279 pages)
    • Roman Missal, 3rd Edition
    • Catechism of Gregorian Rhythm
    • Father Enemond Massé Manuscripts
    • Lalemant Polyphonic
    • Feasts Website
  • Miscellaneous
    • Site Map
    • Secrets of the Conscientious Choirmaster
    • “Wedding March” for lazy organists
    • Emporium Kevin Allen
    • Saint Jean de Lalande Library
    • Sacred Music Symposium 2023
    • The Eight Gregorian Modes
    • Gradual by Pothier’s Protégé
    • Seven (7) Considerations
Views from the Choir Loft

Choir Members Can’t Get Enough of This Piece

Jeff Ostrowski · May 21, 2024

HAVE ALWAYS believed that “conducting from the keyboard” is an insult to the ensemble. (Others will disagree.) I realize that great musicians like Mozart sometimes conducted “from the keyboard.” Nonetheless, the soloist who conducts from the keyboard unconsciously tells the ensemble: “I will conduct you—but only when I’m not busy doing my own stuff.” On the other hand, the conscientious choirmaster frequently has no choice in the matter. For example, when I accompany on the pipe organ I often allow one of my singers to conduct. The problem is, sometimes that singer is absent. That means I’m back to “conducting from the keyboard.” This can be a source of great frustration, especially when members of the choir start to compete with one another. If the conductor is busy playing the organ, this can’t be addressed.

They Love This Piece • Below is a hymn tune choir members absolutely love singing. You will notice a few of the choir members began to “compete with one another”—but there was nothing I could do because I was playing the organ:

To access this hymn’s media in the Brébeuf Portal, click here.

Provenance Problems • That hymn melody (called IOANNES in the Brébeuf Catholic Hymnal) is similar but not identical to a melody from the 1920s called ST BOTOLPH. One difference is that ST BOTOLPH is significantly shorter (86.86.) than IOANNES, which is an 88.88 meter. Tracing the provenance of hymn tunes is notoriously ticklish. One of my professors used to say: “There’s only seven notes in the diatonic scale!” As a result, there’s always “sharing” or “borrowing” or “stealing” that goes on. A famous example is BRESLAU compared to WINCHESTER NEW, as you can see:

Gregorian Rhythm Wars • Years ago, we started a series called “Gregorian Chant Rhythm Wars.” During that series, one of the interlocutors noted (pardon the pun) that hymn melodies’ rhythm often changes. Sometimes “duple” is changed to “triple”—and vice versa. Ancient versions of the hymns are often rather jagged—that is to say, the meter is irregular. According to Dr. Horst Buchholz, Sebastian Bach “smoothed out” many of those tunes for Cantatas and Passions he composed. To give an example of what I’m talking about, consider BRESLAU (mentioned above). Many hymnals print that tune in triple time, although 4/4 is more common:

*  PDF Download • BRESLAU HYMN (Triple)

Poor Analogy (1 of 2) • The interlocutor in Gregorian Rhythm Wars said that because metrical hymnody sometimes has rhythmic variation through the years, that means plainsong’s rhythm could have been radically different in the year 900AD than it was in 950AD. My personal opinion is that his analogy was quite poor. If such a radical change to the fundamentals of Gregorian chant rhythm—let’s say in the year 950AD—I’m absolutely convinced we would have “traces” or “evidence” or “clues” of such a massive recasting. I would bet my life on the fact that no such changed happened. How can I be so sure? One reason is that hundreds of ancient manuscripts have been made available online—yet not one of them betrays a “former” or “authentic” rhythm that was suddenly abandoned … even by accident!

Poor Analogy (2 of 2) • Another reason is that it wouldn’t have been possible to notify everyone in Europe of such a fundamental change. There were no telephones, and travel was extremely dangerous and frightfully difficult. Email was still more than 1,000 years away! Even if such a thing were possible, human beings tend to be contrarian. As a result, surely some of the monasteries would have rejected such a change—preserving this supposed “true” or “original” or “authentic” rhythmic system—but there’s no evidence of that taking place. Not one punctum!

Pothier Vindicated • Indeed, 101 years after the death of Abbat Joseph Pothier, we see that his basic theory—the shockingly consistent “one-to-one correspondence” of the mediæval neumes, broadly speaking—has been strengthened, not diminished. Abbat Pothier stubbornly resisted the idea that 2-3 manuscripts could be elevated above the testimony of thousands of others (which were also very ancient). Abbat Pothier took into consideration the entire manuscript tradition, not just 2-3 manuscripts which were particularly beautiful or happened to be easily accessible, and he was correct to do so. Perhaps Auguste Pécoul (considered the spiritual “son” of Abbat Prosper Guéranger of Solesmes) put it best, writing on 24 June 1901:

“To forestall any confusion, let us remember that there is just one Gregorian notation—that restored, according to the ancient manuscripts, by the eminent Abbot of Saint-Wandrille, Dom Pothier.”

Opinions by blog authors do not necessarily represent the views of Corpus Christi Watershed.

Filed Under: Articles Tagged With: Abbat Joseph Pothier, Abbat Prosper Guéranger, Abbot Joseph Pothier of Solesmes, anti-Pothierists, Auguste Pécoul, Breslau Hymn Tune, Dom Guéranger, Gregorian Rhythm Wars, Veni Creator Spiritus, Winchester New Hymn Last Updated: May 21, 2024

Subscribe

It greatly helps us if you subscribe to our mailing list!

* indicates required

About Jeff Ostrowski

Jeff Ostrowski holds his B.M. in Music Theory from the University of Kansas (2004). He resides with his wife and children in Michigan. —(Read full biography).

Primary Sidebar

Corpus Christi Watershed

President’s Corner

    Typo in the “Missale Romanum” (1962)
    The 1962 MISSALE ROMANUM was a transitional missal. It was on its way to becoming the 1970 version, but wasn’t there yet. It eliminated certain duplications, downplayed the Prayers at the Foot of the Altar, expanded the role of laymen, minimized the Last Gospel, made many items optional, and so forth. Father Valentine Young spotted many typos in the 1962 MISSALE ROMANUM, especially incorrect accents. The Offertory Antiphon for this coming Sunday (OF kalendar) contains an error, citing the wrong verse from Psalm 118. It should be 118:107b, not 118:154. If you read verse 154, you’ll understand how that error crept in. [In this particular case, the error pre-dates the 1962 Missal, since the 1940s hand-missal by Father Lasance also gets it wrong.]
    —Jeff Ostrowski
    “Music List” • 30th in Ordinary Time (Year C)
    Readers have expressed interest in perusing the ORDER OF MUSIC I’ve prepared for 26 October 2025, which is the 30th Sunday in Ordinary Time (Year C). If such a thing interests you, feel free to download it as a PDF file. As always, the Responsorial Psalm, Gospel Acclamation, and Mass Propers for this Sunday are conveniently stored at the top-notch feasts website alongside the official texts in Latin.
    —Jeff Ostrowski
    Little Encouragement?
    In the Gospel, our Savior tells about 10 lepers who were healed. Only one went back to give thanks. Precious few express gratitude, yet many have endless energy to complain. For that reason, I deeply appreciate receiving messages like the following, which arrived a few days ago (about the parish where I direct in Michigan): “Last Sunday, a couple I knew from Grand Rapids was at Mass at 10:00 a.m. I got a chance to talk to them after Mass. I wanted to let you know what they said about the choir. They were absolutely floored by our sound!!!!! They both said they could continuously listen to our choir and the beauty of it. They asked me: “Do you always sound like that?” And they were also very surprised at how packed the church was. They said it was nice for them to be in such a full church. I just thought you would be interested to know their thoughts about our choir.”
    —Jeff Ostrowski

Quick Thoughts

    “Our Father” • Musical Setting?
    Looking through a Roman Catholic Hymnal published in 1859 by Father Guido Maria Dreves (d. 1909), I stumbled upon this very beautiful tune (PDF file). I feel it would be absolutely perfect to set the “Our Father” in German to music. Thoughts?
    —Jeff Ostrowski
    New Bulletin Article • “12 October 2025”
    My pastor requested that I write short articles each week for our parish bulletin. Those responsible for preparing similar write-ups may find a bit of inspiration in these brief columns. The latest article (dated 12 October 2025) talks about an ‘irony’ or ‘paradox’ regarding the 1960s switch to a wider use (amplior locus) of vernacular in the liturgy.
    —Jeff Ostrowski
    “American Catholic Hymnal” (1991)
    The American Catholic Hymnal, with IMPRIMATUR granted (25 April 1991) by the Archdiocese of Chicago, is like a compendium of every horrible idea from the 1980s. Imagine being forced to stand all through Communion (even afterwards) when those self-same ‘enlightened’ liturgists moved the SEQUENCE before the Alleluia to make sure congregations wouldn’t have to stand during it. (Even worse, everything about the SEQUENCE—including its name—means it should follow the Alleluia.) And imagine endlessly repeating “Alleluia” during Holy Communion at every single Mass. It was all part of an effort to convince people that Holy Communion was historically a procession (which it wasn’t).
    —Jeff Ostrowski

Random Quote

“I prefer to preach,” said one priest “even without immediate preparation, for I can always draw—from the various studies stored away during the seminary years—enough material to interest our good Catholic people. But when I have to go to the altar and sing High Mass or a Requiem, and I know that I cannot read a note of the Preface and the ‘Pater Noster’, I feel like going to martyrdom. Yet the notes are right there before my eyes, but they seem to mock my ignorance.”

— From a 1920 article by Very Rev. Leo P. Manzetti

Recent Posts

  • A Practical Method of Projecting Solfege for Chant
  • PDF Downloads • Four (4) Simple Pieces in Harmony for Men’s Choirs
  • Typo in the “Missale Romanum” (1962)
  • “Music List” • 30th in Ordinary Time (Year C)
  • “Our Father” • Musical Setting?

Subscribe

Subscribe

* indicates required

Copyright © 2025 Corpus Christi Watershed · Isaac Jogues on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in

Corpus Christi Watershed is a 501(c)3 public charity dedicated to exploring and embodying as our calling the relationship of religion, culture, and the arts. This non-profit organization employs the creative media in service of theology, the Church, and Christian culture for the enrichment and enjoyment of the public.