• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Corpus Christi Watershed

“What earlier generations held as sacred, remains sacred and great for us too…” Pope Benedict XVI (7 July 2007)

  • About
  • Symposium
  • Hymnal
  • Jogues Missal
  • Site Map
  • Donate
Views from the Choir Loft

(Installment #4) “Catholic Hymnals” • Charles Weaver

Charles Weaver · September 2, 2020

Editor’s Note: Each contributor is reflecting upon Comparison of 15 Traditional Catholic Hymnals. Rather than rehashing Mr. Craig’s article, they were given freedom to “expand upon” this vast subject. Click here to read all the installments that have appeared so far.

READ WITH GREAT delight Daniel Craig’s article, because I share his great respect for careful hymn editors. Hymns are such a conspicuous and ever-present feature of the way people experience liturgy in a parish setting, even if they are secondary to the tradition of plainchant. Good hymnody marries memorable music with excellent poetry in a way that enhances both components. Mr. Craig’s review thoroughly examines the way several current hymnals accomplish this (or attempt to).

One important and underappreciated aspect of hymnody is the tendency of tunes to mutate and evolve over time. Music is a language, and as with all languages its pronunciation and usage change. Hymn tunes and styles of singing and accompanying are very different now from a mere 150 years ago, just as the texts are. To most modern listeners, the original versions of beloved hymn tunes (for instance, ST THOMAS) would sound strange and jarring. In creating a hymnal, the compilers must sift through countless variants, considering issues of fidelity to the source, appropriateness of style, compatibility with the text, singability by a congregation, and oral tradition of familiar tunes. All of that comes before even considering the harmonization!

“Holy God, We Praise Thy Name”

As an example, consider “Holy God, we praise thy Name,” which in many parishes is sung every single day. As is typical for ubiquitous tunes, this melody goes by at least five different names, and has been associated with many texts. Of course, in the Catholic tradition, it is linked almost exclusively with the Te Deum, and is widely used at Benediction of the Blessed Sacrament. The tune originates in an Austrian Catholic songbook of the eighteenth century, paired with a metered text that paraphrases Augustine and Ambrose’s great improvisation. The German serves as a model for Fr. Walworth’s English—six-line stanzas that rhyme ABABCC. Here is how the original went:

Grosser Gott from Katholisches Gesangbuch

There are some minor melodic differences from the modern version we all know, but the melody as a whole is recognizable, and you could easily sing the English words to this tune. Notice that each musical phrase begins and ends on the same notes as the familar version. More revealing are the large-scale differences. The AAB form (not to be confused with the text’s rhyme scheme) is typical of German hymns, whereas in this country the form is often rounded out to AABB by repeating the second half (we usually sing “Infinite thy vast domain” twice). The compound meter would also never occur to an English speaker; we have a strong preference for the last accented syllable of each line to fall on a downbeat. This kind of compound barring for tunes was completely normal in eighteenth-century German-speaking countries. And while this setting is lovely, the harmony and bass are as simple as possible (only primary chords with a functional rather than melodic bass), which would be a fault in a modern hymnal.

Holy God from The Catholic Psalmist

By the time of Lyons’s The Catholic Psalmist, from 1859, we have the modern tune paired with something like the modern text. The B section is still not repeated. But the melodic ascent in the B section has the skipping eighth notes that many of us know now. Such ornaments are frequent in nineteenth-century hymns, and modern editors tend to excise them, as they have a tendency to sound like folk music. Consider this example on the very next page:

Adeste Fideles from The Catholic Psalmist

I have never heard anyone sing eighth notes there. By the same logic, many editors remove the eighth notes in “Holy God.” These ornaments often lead to contrapuntal flaws, as shown here:

Hypothetical parallel octaves in a hymn harmonization
The contrary motion in version a is a natural way to approach this half cadence. Version b results in parallel octaves. Admittedly, I don’t think these octaves sound bad, as the underlying motion is still the one shown in version a. Indeed, one of the better modern harmonizations from the list of fifteen hymnals does exactly what is shown in version b.

In this case, the oral tradition may have won out. I have attended Benediction services where the organist steadfastly played quarter notes throughout (as was printed in the books in the pews), and the congregation serenely went on with these chordal leaps, often creating the situation in example b. This seems to go against the spirit of the act of communal singing. What is the right editorial practice in this case? I think a good editor, and indeed a good choir director, would take many factors into consideration.


I don’t have all fifteen of the hymnals in question, but of the ones I do have, it is interesting to see how the editors handle these questions. I think the choices in this hymn reinforce Mr. Craig’s assessment well, so I will mention only two in particular. The New Westminster Hymnal uses quarter notes and no repeat. This streamlines the tune and makes it more hymn-like—more similar to other tunes that populate our hymnals. Hymns, Songs, and Spiritual Canticles has the eighth notes and the repeat, which is written out in full with a deceptive cadence the first time, which gives a musical reason for the repetition. Marier’s harmonization in particular is daring and fresh (and with his usual impeccable counterpoint), which is perfect for such a widely known hymn.

All of these niceties serve a purpose—because of whom we are working for, we must work out every detail of our work on sacred music with great care and reverence. This applies not only to musicians, but also (and perhaps even more) to those who make the books we sing from. This is the theme I see running through Mr. Craig’s article, and may it be a lesson to us all to spare no effort on details.

Opinions by blog authors do not necessarily represent the views of Corpus Christi Watershed.

Follow the Discussion on Facebook

Filed Under: Articles Tagged With: Holy God We Praise Thy Name, Traditional Catholic Hymnals Last Updated: September 8, 2020

Subscribe to the CCW Mailing List

About Charles Weaver

Charles Weaver is on the faculty of the Juilliard School, and serves as director of music for St. Mary’s Church. He lives in Connecticut with his wife and four children.—(Read full biography).

Primary Sidebar

Corpus Christi Watershed

Quick Thoughts

Alabama Assessment!

We received this evaluation of Symposium 2022 from an Alabama participant:

“Oh, how the Symposium echoed the words of Cardinal Merry Del Val: …choosing only what is most conformed to Thy glory, which is my final aim. In one short and fast paced week, the faculty and attendees showed me the hand of God and our Lady working in our lives. The wide range of education—from Gregorian Chant, jazz modes in organ improvisation, to ‘staying sane’ while leading a choir—were certainly first-class knowledge from the best teachers of the art. However, the most powerful lesson was learning how to pray as a choir. The sacrifice of putting songs together, taking time to learn the sacred text, meditating on the church teaching through the chants, and gaining the virtues required to persevere in these duties were not only qualities of a choir but of a saint. The sanctification of the lives of the attendees was a beautiful outcome of this event … and that in itself is worth more than a beautifully-sung Solesmes style chant!”

—Jeff Ostrowski
PDF Download • Trinity Sunday (22 pages)

Feel free to download this Organ Accompaniment Booklet for Trinity Sunday (Second Vespers). Notice how the modes progress by number. Psalm 1 is mode 1; Psalm 2 is mode 2; Psalm 3 is mode 3; Psalm 4 is mode 4; Psalm 5 is mode 5. I am told by an expert that other feasts (such as Corpus Christi) are likewise organized by mode, and it’s called a “numerical office.”

—Jeff Ostrowski
10 June 2022 • “Official” rhythm of plainsong

I continue to search for the most beautiful way to present the “pure” Editio Vaticana scores. (Technically, the “pure” rhythm of the official edition is what everyone is supposed to use.) You can download my latest attempt, which is the Introit for this coming Sunday: Feast of the Most Holy Trinity. Because this is not an ancient feast, the Introit had to be adapted (perhaps around 750AD). Prior Johner says the adaptation is “not an entirely happy one.”

—Jeff Ostrowski

Random Quote

“Although the Mass contains much instruction for the faithful, it has nevertheless not seemed expedient to the fathers that it be celebrated everywhere in the vernacular. The holy synod commands pastors and everyone who has the care of souls to explain frequently during the celebration of the Masses, either themselves or through others, some of the things that are read in the Mass, and among other things to expound some mystery of this most Holy Sacrifice, especially on Sundays and feastdays.”

— ‘Council of Trent, XII:8 (1562)’

Recent Posts

  • “Chant Rhythm Wars” • Dueling Lectures!
  • “I Decided to Get a Plane Ticket and Fly 8,700 Miles From Singapore to Take Part.”
  • Alabama Assessment!
  • “How Has Nobody Done This Before?” • Vol. 1
  • “Exceeded Every Expectation!” • Mr. O’Brien’s Review

Copyright © 2022 Corpus Christi Watershed · Gabriel Lalemant on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in

Corpus Christi Watershed is a 501(c)3 public charity dedicated to exploring and embodying as our calling the relationship of religion, culture, and the arts. This non-profit organization employs the creative media in service of theology, the Church, and Christian culture for the enrichment and enjoyment of the public.