HOPE THE BENEVOLENT reader will allow me to say a word about “giving people the sacred music they want.” Should the conscientious choirmaster give people the sacred music they want? I would suggest a mixture. On the one hand, we want to “push” or “lead” or “escort” Catholics on their journey to explore (and ultimately fall in love with, crave, and draw strength from) sacred music with real depth or richness. On the other hand, each of us is in the midst of a journey of our own. It would be foolish to expect everyone to be at the same “point” or “level of understanding” we’re at. Some are behind us, while others are ahead of us. Therefore, I feel the conscientious choirmaster should employ a mixture. In other words, we should take into consideration compositions our singers crave. We should not feel ‘resentment’ toward them for (perhaps) not having yet reached the level of understanding we’ve attained.
A Perfect Example! • I can’t think of a better example—to illustrate my point—than the ISTE CONFESSOR hymn. First, listen to it:
Note: That version was recorded yesterday morning by my students. It was created for an exciting new Spanish Hymnal which is forthcoming.
The Story Behind It • Now I will explain the story behind the ISTE CONFESSOR hymn. Years ago, during Vespers at the SACRED MUSIC SYMPOSIUM, I wrote an SATB harmonization for ISTE CONFESSOR. (Because the entire ceremony of Vespers is sung is plainsong, we often use a metrical setting as the Vespers hymn for the sake of variety.) The participants went nuts over it. Many of them became “obsessed” with my SATB arrangement. They sang it in coffee shops—if you’re familiar with the concept of a “flash mob”—and sometimes got kicked out. They went home and sang it with their choirs. Indeed, a group of young participants even formed a virtual choir to produce this fabulous recording.
Each year, I’d spend (literally) weeks editing about 300 pages of music for each SACRED MUSIC SYMPOSIUM. We always had a different theme. For example, one year was completely dedicated to a Gregorian hymn—and the conference culminated with a stupendous Mass by Palestrina based upon that melody. I thought the participants would appreciate always having a bunch of new music—but (believe it or not) some participants came to the conference each year just to sing the ISTE CONFESSOR hymn. And that’s just fine!
Summary • When it comes to the “sacred music journey,” we must remember that everyone is at a different point. For this reason, I believe the conscientious choirmaster will use a mixture of nova et vetera. It’s quite unprofessional for a choir director to walk around “jaded,” constantly downplaying—or even ridiculing!—new members who are thrilled when they experience a simple 2-voice harmony for the first time.
P.S.
For the record, below is one instance of the ISTE CONFESSOR hymn as it appears in the Brébeuf Keyboard Edition:
The melody ISTE CONFESSOR is used in the Brébeuf Hymnal as #724 and also #54. The melody was included on page 416 in the London Oratory’s Catholic Hymn Book (1998). It can also be found on page 221 of the Worship II Hymnal (GIA, 1975). The melody seems to have originated in a VESPERALE (Poitiers, 1746). Organists who desire harmonies for the “final verses” should consult #106 of Richard Lloyd’s collection (1993) #106 or #168 of Noel Rawsthorne’s collection (2011).
